
“Experience is Not the Best Teacher”
Father Peter Fitzgibbons
March 15 – 16, 2025
Gospel: Luke 9:28b-36
You have heard it said that experience is the best teacher. But that’s not true. If it were, there would be no alcoholics. People would get drunk only once in their lives to avoid nausea, vomiting, and pounding headaches. Does that sound like fun to anybody? No. Experience is not the best teacher because we tend to forget about the pain. It is also not the best teacher for good experiences.
In today’s Gospel, we have another epiphany, which means the manifestation of Who Christ is. Jesus lowered the veil of His humanity that He took from the Blessed Mother to reveal His Divinity. This epiphany was given to strengthen the Apostles for the Passion, which would occur ten days later. Peter, James, and John, who were the three lead Apostles, Peter being the most senior, had, by that time, seen at least three dead people raised to life. The Apostles were there when Jesus fed loaves and fishes to the 5,000. They were there when He walked on water and cured leprosy. According to Scripture, not all our Lord’s miracles were written down, and even though the Apostles saw all His miracles, what happened ten days after this epiphany? When Jesus entered into His Passion, the Apostles were nowhere to be found.
Now you may be thinking, “Lord, if I had just one of the experiences like the Apostles had, I would never doubt You again.” Yes, you would . . . We all would. We are fallen creatures because of Original Sin, the sins we have committed after Baptism, and the wrongs committed against us by others. “But I want a religious experience.” Religious experiences are given to us by God. Sometimes, He gives them to us before we undergo a great trial to help us prepare for it. Sometimes, He gives them to us as an atta-boy or atta-girl. Other times, God gives us religious experiences just to say, “I love you, and I’m still with you. I haven’t forgotten about you.” But it is as God decides and not as we decide. You cannot go to any church and have a religious experience on demand. Nor does it happen every time we pray. That just doesn’t happen. God doesn’t come when we want Him to. I wish He did. I would have been a monsignor a long time ago. I’m only 71 and have been a priest for 40 years. But I’m a patient man. He comes to strengthen our souls, to give us comfort, and sometimes for no reason at all. He is God, and He decides when to come to us.
“Every time I go to church, I feel good.” Really. Intellectually or emotionally? Emotionally, you probably won’t. Intellectually, you may because you are in the presence of Jesus Christ in the Blessed Sacrament and part of the Holy Sacrifice. That’s a wonderful thing. However, because of our fallen nature, we don’t always feel that way. When we feel the Lord has abandoned us, even though He hasn’t, that is when we grow most in faith. He never has and never will abandon us. Just because we don’t feel His presence, doesn’t mean He isn’t there. Drive up Highway 52 at 70 mph and let me know how that works out for you. “I didn’t see the cop!” But he saw you. Cops are very good at hiding. How many of you have seen your guardian angel? Very few have. Saint Teresa de Lisieux and Saint Francis of Assisi saw theirs. But just because you cannot see them, doesn’t mean that they aren’t there. Can you see your house from here? I can. But if you can’t, that doesn’t mean it’s not there – you just can’t see it. The same is true for God’s love and His presence around you.
So do not be disturbed by a lack of religious experiences. God does not judge you on that. God judges you on the constancy of your love and following Him whether you find it pleasant or not. Hanging on to your faith is an act of Will. We want to always be happy, joyous, and free, but that is not possible in this life. That will happen only in the next life. Keep the faith. Do the next right thing. And remember that our Lord is always there as a refuge no matter what suffering you are going through.
How will you apply this message to your life? _________________________________________
You can read all of Father Fitzgibbons’ sermons by going to AnnunciationCatholicAlbemarle.com, clicking on “Blog” then “Categories” and then “Sermon Notes.” On a cell phone: click on “Blog” and then “Menu.” Scroll to the bottom and click on “Categories.” Sermon Notes are also available on the Church’s Facebook page at OLA.Catholic.Church. Click on “Groups” and then “Sermon Notes.